The sample seen here should give you a framework of the type of analysis we are looking for in this project. Please note that this sample does not include a reflection. Submissions must include a reflection.

Portfolio Section 1: Case Study

This particular example is a company the film industry. The company consists of 1,500 employees. The Company went through a recent process of centralizing several support functions. These functions included, employee and labor relations, total rewards, talent acquisition, marketing and internal communications, and human resources operations. The simulant for centralization was to control costs, provide consistency with processes and to ensure data integrity. While the concept of centralizing support functions has been one that is embraced by many organizations as a way to manage and control costs, The Company has had difficulty with this transition. Partly because change is difficult for many to accept even when it is for the right reasons, more importantly for the Company it is due to their core values. These values are incredibly appropriate for navigation through change, being responsive and respectful to clients and peers, and continuing the initial vision. However when taken to extreme as in the case of this project, the leadership has lead the department to a stalemated position.

The draw back is that these values stand in the way of leaders taking a stand and providing the necessary direction for change to be successful. The Company is a case in which the values may be causing a mental roadblock to the change. In other words, the CEO is holding back. This change is the right change, but he is unwilling to take that hard line of accept or move on with the opposing executives.

For purposes of this paper the focus will be on three items that reside in the talent acquisition department, which is a sub-department of the Human Resources Division.

Talent Acquisition is comprised of 5 recruiters, 1 coordinators, operations manager, 1 regional recruiting managers and Director. The current statistics of the department are 300 open positions, filling approximately 10 positions per month. When this department was moved to a centralized function, 100 thousand dollars was removed from the budget, leaving the department to manage the recruitment processes with less. Handicapping the department with fewer resources, while expecting better results.

The department was then challenged to improve performance through the quality and quantity of candidates, systems enhancements, and process improvement. Over a three year time frame the department limped along requesting for more resources and always being denied the necessary support to complete the initiatives. In an effort to help resolve the issue, a project team was formed to design a better staffing model for the TA department. The stakeholders for TA would be the HR leaders, corporate executives, and hiring managers. This group of individuals is impacted the most when the TA function is deficient in operation. The criteria used to create the project team participants were based on their immediate connection with the functions being evaluated; the length of time in their individual role, along with the scope of their role. Behavioral characteristics of the individual participants, have they exhibited an ability to embrace change, are they individual that have supportive behaviors and problem solving abilities. Since the idea of this change is to impact an employee population of 1,500, it was critically important to comprise the group of individuals that were results driven, supportive, have the ability to commit to decision and plans of action, hold one another accountable for delivering against the plans, and finally focus on the achievement of collective results.

When the project team was formed there became one team member consistently taking the lead and directing all the team members to follow and accept their decisions. While all of the team members are at the same level in the organization, this one member always assumes the leader role, not allowing for anyone else’s opinion to be considered. In the beginning, it was okay, because the team was able to accomplish the projects quickly. Now it is becoming more problematic because the team members are feeling frustrated that many of their ideas are not being considered, and often times, the team has not made the right decision.

Portfolio Section 2: Concepts

While the initial impression of the situation is interpreted to be functional, over time, it clearly becomes a destructive situation. The source of conflict is one of power. Since clear responsibilities were not established during the initial stages of forming the team, one individual has been able to step up and take the lead. This action should not be interpreted as taking initiative. This is a clear example of power, control and destructive behavior. The level of conflict rests strongly in the role area as this also stems from ambiguity and unclear expectations between the positions of the team.

As with any team dynamics, communication plays a strong role. This case study has outlined the source and level of conflict that can develop if clear lines of communication are not established when forming the team. Ensuring that there are clear responsibilities as well as defined communication expectations would help prevent or minimize issues and conflicts.

While participants may avoid conflict initially by surrendering their right to voice opinions, in the long run, the team’s dynamics will buckle due to the exclusion of its members. Unresolved issues can become very costly to the company if the issues go unresolved. This type of behavior, if left unchecked, will result in an immediate loss to the department’s bottom line. If the issues are allowed to continue, employees will become disengaged.

One of the core challenges for the formation of the team was that the individuals prior to working together as a team were not asked to voice their concerns. Sending an email out introducing the project initiatives, explaining the processes that would be reviewed, and outlining the decisions that would need to be made is critical to the successful launch of any team. In addition, calling participants in advance of the first project team meeting to ask exploratory questions to help stimulate the dialogue that will be necessary to have in order to complete the decision making processes and launch any recommendations.

Working with these exploratory questions prior to the first meeting will act as a method to flush out and discover who were committed to being part of the solution. So when moving towards the first meeting the team would know those that were most resistant to any change that might be a contradiction to their intended goal or desired outcome. Small steps such as these are huge time savers and allow the initial stages of team development to start on a stronger footing.

Portfolio Section 3: Action Plan

The best place to start to resolving this case study would be through active listening skills. It will be important to establish a framework of dialogue to ensure the team member who has assumed the leadership role does not become defensive. By showing a level of respect despite their frustration, the other team members can encourage the person in the leadership role to see things from the others’ perspective.

The team will need to move from the avoidance stage to collaboration, and the only way to navigate this move is to identify how the team got to this point of performance. Speaking directly to the facts -- decisions and outcomes -- will allow the team to look objectively at how it got to where it is today. This will also allow each member, even the “leader,” to see how he or she underperformed The “leader” might see that he or she was too controlling; the other members might recognize that they surrendered too readily.

For future meetings, an agenda will be established that will outline the subject, the team member responsible for providing the input or information on that particular agenda item, and the allotted time for the subject to be discussed. A note-taker will be identified to ensure that all information shared during the meeting is recorded. Providing this level of structure will allow the team to be collectively responsible for each decision made, and will support more effective dialogue for better resolution and project recommendations.